Litigation Holds in Microsoft 365: Preserving Law Firm Data In Place
Published · 10 min read

A litigation hold in Microsoft 365 is a setting that preserves a mailbox, OneDrive, SharePoint site or Team so nothing relevant can be permanently deleted, even if a user deletes it. Law firms use Litigation Hold, eDiscovery holds and retention policies to meet preservation duties when litigation is reasonably anticipated, often without buying a separate email archive, as long as the right licenses and settings are in place.
Key takeaways
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e) lets a court order curative measures, or in cases of intent to deprive, adverse inferences or dismissal, when electronically stored information is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it.
- Exchange Online Litigation Hold requires an Exchange Online Plan 2 license, or Plan 1 plus Exchange Online Archiving, and Microsoft 365 Business Premium, E3 and E5 already include archiving.
- Microsoft Purview eDiscovery holds cover mailboxes, OneDrive, SharePoint sites and Teams, but users working eDiscovery cases need a Microsoft 365 Enterprise E3 or E5 license.
- A hold placed before a departing attorney's account is deleted keeps the mailbox as an inactive mailbox instead of losing it after 30 days.
- Holds preserve data inside the same tenant, so they are not a backup and do not replace protection against ransomware or a compromised admin account.
What does a litigation hold in Microsoft 365 actually do?
A hold stops Microsoft 365 from permanently removing content from the locations you place on hold. Deleted and edited items are kept in a hidden location that an authorized administrator can search and export.
For Exchange mailboxes, Microsoft explains that held items are kept in the Recoverable Items folder, including deleted items and the original versions of modified items. When a user mailbox is placed on Litigation Hold, the archive mailbox is held too. For SharePoint and OneDrive, retained copies go to a Preservation Hold library on the site. For Teams chats, retained messages live in a hidden SubstrateHolds folder inside the mailbox.
Why do law firms need to get preservation right?
Because losing relevant electronic information can lead to court sanctions and ethics exposure. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37(e) covers electronically stored information that should have been preserved in the anticipation or conduct of litigation and is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it.
A court that finds prejudice may order measures to cure it. If it finds intent to deprive, it may presume the information was unfavorable, instruct the jury accordingly, or dismiss the action or enter a default judgment.
The ABA Model Rules point the same way. Model Rule 3.4(a) says a lawyer shall not unlawfully obstruct another party's access to evidence or unlawfully alter, destroy or conceal material having potential evidentiary value. Comment 8 to Model Rule 1.1 says lawyers should keep abreast of the benefits and risks associated with relevant technology. The attorneys decide when the duty starts and what it covers under their state rules and case law. IT makes sure the hold works.
Which Microsoft 365 hold should a law firm use?
Use an eDiscovery hold for a specific matter, Litigation Hold for a quick mailbox-only preservation, and retention policies for long-term record keeping. Microsoft describes retention as long-term and broad, and eDiscovery holds as short-term and user-specific, lasting until an administrator releases them.
- Litigation Hold (Exchange only). Preserves an entire mailbox and its archive, indefinitely or for a set number of days. Microsoft still supports it but recommends retention policies or eDiscovery holds as the newer approach.
- eDiscovery hold (Microsoft Purview). Tied to a case. Covers Exchange mailboxes, OneDrive accounts, SharePoint sites, and the mailboxes and sites behind Teams and Microsoft 365 Groups. You can hold everything in a location or use a query-based hold, though Microsoft notes that query-based, time-bound and custodian-scoped holds need higher tiers such as E5 or the E5 eDiscovery and Audit add-on.
- Retention policies and labels. Firm-wide rules that support your records schedule but are not matter-specific.
When several holds or retention rules apply, content under an eDiscovery hold cannot be permanently deleted by any retention policy or label.
What licenses does a firm need for litigation holds?
Check licensing before you need a hold. Microsoft states that an Exchange Online mailbox must have an Exchange Online Plan 2 license to be placed on Litigation Hold, or a Plan 1 license plus a separate Exchange Online Archiving license.
Microsoft's Exchange Online Archiving service description lists Exchange Online Plan 2, Microsoft 365 Business Premium, Microsoft 365 E3 and Microsoft 365 E5 among the plans that already include archiving. Business Basic and Business Standard do not include Litigation Hold and need the add-on.
eDiscovery cases are different. Microsoft states that both admins and users working with eDiscovery cases require a Microsoft 365 Enterprise E3 or E5 license. A Business Premium firm may need an enterprise license for whoever runs cases. Shared mailboxes, such as an intake or docketing box, also need a Plan 2 or Plan 1 plus Archiving license to go on hold.
How do you place a hold that covers email, Teams and files?
Identify every location where a custodian's data lives, then hold each one and confirm it applied. Mailbox-only holds miss a lot.
Microsoft's Teams guidance maps where content is stored:
- 1:1 chats, group chats and private channel conversations are stored in each user's mailbox.
- Standard and shared channel messages are stored in the mailbox of the parent team.
- Files in standard channels are stored in the team's SharePoint site, while private and shared channel files sit in a dedicated SharePoint site for that channel.
- A user's private files are in their OneDrive account.
A sound hold for one custodian covers their mailbox and archive, OneDrive, every team they belong to, and any matter SharePoint sites they used. Watch for these traps Microsoft documents:
- Group membership is captured when the hold is created. People added to a distribution list or team later are not automatically held, so re-add the group when membership changes.
- A new hold isn't applied instantly. Microsoft advises confirming the hold is applied, using PowerShell, before relying on it or deleting an account.
- The SharePoint Recycle Bin isn't indexed, so eDiscovery can't find or hold content that is only in the Recycle Bin.
Document what you held, when, who asked and how you verified it.
What happens when an attorney on hold leaves the firm?
Apply or confirm a hold before you delete the account, or the mailbox may be lost. Microsoft explains that when a Microsoft 365 account is removed, the mailbox data is kept for 30 days and then permanently removed, unless a hold was applied first, in which case the mailbox becomes an inactive mailbox.
Microsoft recommends retention policies for former staff, because an inactive mailbox kept only by an eDiscovery case hold is permanently deleted when that case closes or the hold is released. Microsoft also cautions not to change a departing user's UPN or primary email address before deleting the account, because that can prevent you from managing the inactive mailbox later.
Build this into offboarding: legal confirms whether the person is a custodian, IT confirms hold status, and only then is the account deleted.
Can a hold replace a separate archive or backup?
A hold can replace a separate archive for preservation in many small firms, but it cannot replace a backup. Holds keep content inside the same tenant. If an attacker gains admin rights or a hold is removed by mistake, you need a copy outside those controls.
Microsoft itself draws this line. Its inactive mailbox guidance says recovering data from an inactive mailbox with an auto-expanding archive through content search is supported for eDiscovery purposes only and can't be used as a backup solution.
The workable model for most firms is holds and retention for legal preservation, plus independent Microsoft 365 backup for recovery. For the wider set of controls firms need around client data, see our overview of what cybersecurity law firms need.
How should a law firm set up its hold process before it is needed?
Write the process down, test it once, and assign owners, so the first urgent matter doesn't reveal a license gap.
- Confirm licensing. List which mailboxes, shared mailboxes and eDiscovery users have the licenses described above.
- Set firm-wide retention. Align Microsoft 365 retention policies with your records retention schedule so email and files aren't deleted early by default.
- Define roles. Limit eDiscovery permissions to named people.
- Create a hold template. A checklist for each custodian: mailbox, archive, OneDrive, Teams, SharePoint sites, shared mailboxes.
- Tie holds to offboarding. No account deletion until legal clears it and IT confirms hold status.
- Run a test hold. Place a hold on a test user, delete content, and confirm you can find it in eDiscovery.
- Review open holds quarterly. Release a hold only when the attorneys say so.
For the related duties, see ABA ethics and cybersecurity for law firms and our law firm data breach response guide.
What else do law firms ask about Microsoft 365 litigation holds?
Will the user know their mailbox is on hold?
Not unless you tell them. Litigation Hold has optional note and URL fields that can display a message to the user in Outlook, and if they are left blank the user isn't notified. The written hold notice to custodians is a separate legal step.
Can we hold only email from a certain date range?
Yes, with a query-based eDiscovery hold that preserves content sent, received or created within a range. Microsoft notes that query-based and time-bound holds need higher license tiers such as E5 or the eDiscovery and Audit add-on.
Do we still need a third-party email archive?
Not always for preservation, if your licenses and retention settings are right. You still need a separate backup for recovery, because holds stay inside the same tenant.
If you want a quick view of where your firm stands, start with our free security check, or read more practical posts in our legal industry resources. NorthStar helps firms configure Microsoft 365 retention, holds and backup as part of managed IT and cybersecurity for law firms.
Sources
- Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 37 (Legal Information Institute)
- ABA Model Rule 3.4: Fairness to Opposing Party and Counsel
- ABA Model Rule 1.1: Competence, Comment
- Microsoft Learn: Place a mailbox on litigation hold
- Microsoft Learn: Create holds in eDiscovery
- Microsoft Learn: Place a Microsoft Teams user or team on legal hold
- Microsoft Learn: Learn about inactive mailboxes
- Microsoft Learn: Learn about retention policies and retention labels
- Microsoft Learn: Get started with eDiscovery
- Microsoft Learn: Exchange Online Archiving service description
Industry Resources
Managed IT and Cybersecurity for Law Firms
NorthStar helps law firms set up Microsoft 365 retention, litigation holds, backup and security controls that support their preservation and confidentiality duties.
Learn More →About the author

Ken Satkunam, CISM
President & Founder, NorthStar Technology Group
Ken has spent over 25 years in IT leadership, serving in roles from technical support to CIO for organizations as large as 23,000 employees. He founded NorthStar Technology Group in 2000 to help regulated organizations build secure, compliant, and operationally resilient technology environments. Ken holds the Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) credential from ISACA and is the co-author of the Amazon best-seller "Cyber Attack Prevention." He has been quoted in industry publications including eWeek and DM News, and NorthStar has been recognized on the Inc. 5000 list in both 2024 and 2025.