Risk Assessments for CMMC Compliance: What DoD Contractors Need
Published · Last updated · 10 min read

For defense contractors, the question is no longer whether to conduct a cybersecurity risk assessment—it's how to do it correctly before a contracting officer or a Certified Third-Party Assessment Organization (C3PAO) does it for you. The CMMC program rule, 32 CFR Part 170, was published October 15, 2024 and took effect December 16, 2024. The DFARS CMMC rule, including clause 252.204-7021, was published September 10, 2025 and took effect November 10, 2025, which started Phase 1. On July 13, 2026, the Department of War suspended Phase II (C3PAO Level 2 as a condition of award, originally set for November 10, 2026). Phase I self-assessment requirements remain in place. A C3PAO assessment is not automatically required for every Level 2 contract while Phase 2 is paused. Inaccurate self-assessments can still create legal exposure, including under the False Claims Act. Understanding the risk-assessment process (what it requires, what it costs, and where contractors most often fail) is foundational. For official status, see our 2026 CMMC timeline and levels guide and the official CMMC program page.
What Is an SPRS Score and How Does It Relate to a CMMC Risk Assessment?
The Supplier Performance Risk System (SPRS) is where contractors post a NIST SP 800-171 DoD Assessment score. If DFARS 252.204-7012 applies and you handle CUI, DFARS 252.204-7019 and 252.204-7020 require you to post a current score through PIEE, and to keep it current. The scoring method starts at 110 points and subtracts for unimplemented requirements, with some requirements weighted more heavily than others. There is no official passing SPRS score. An inaccurate score, especially one that overstates your posture, can create legal exposure, including under the False Claims Act.
Your SPRS score and your CMMC status are related, but they are not the same thing. The 88-point threshold discussed later in this article is a CMMC conditional-status rule under 32 CFR 170.21, not an official "passing" SPRS score. For the 110-point method, how to post a score, and how SPRS relates to CMMC, see our guide to SPRS scoring for defense contractors.
What Types of CMMC Assessments Exist?
CMMC under 32 CFR Part 170 uses a tiered assessment structure. Phase 1 allows solicitations to require Level 1 or Level 2 self-assessments. A C3PAO Level 2 assessment as a condition of award was the Phase 2 step, now suspended. Some solicitations may still include a C3PAO assessment at the Department's discretion, but it is not the default for every Level 2 contract.
- Level 1 self-assessment (annual): Contractors handling only Federal Contract Information (FCI) conduct an annual self-assessment against 17 practices aligned with FAR 52.204-21 and enter results in SPRS. A C3PAO is not required for Level 1. A plan of action and milestones is not permitted for Level 1 self-assessments under 32 CFR 170.21.
- Level 2 Self-Assessment (Every 3 Years): Some Level 2 contracts allow self-assessment. Contractors assess themselves against all 110 NIST SP 800-171 Rev. 2 controls using the DoD Assessment Methodology, enter their score in SPRS, and provide an annual affirmation to maintain CMMC status. Conditional status is allowed if POA&Ms are documented with closure within 180 days.
- Level 2 C3PAO assessment (typically every three years, when required): A C3PAO is a third-party assessment organization accredited by the Cyber AB. It performs a Level 2 certification assessment against all 110 NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2 requirements through document review, interviews, and technical testing. Results are entered in SPRS by the C3PAO. Status is typically good for three years, with annual affirmation. This path applies when a contract or solicitation actually requires it, not automatically to every CUI contract while Phase 2 is paused. For how to prepare, see our C3PAO readiness guide.
- Level 3 DIBCAC Assessment (Every 3 Years): The highest-sensitivity CUI programs require a government-conducted assessment by DCMA's Defense Industrial Base Cybersecurity Assessment Center (DIBCAC), evaluating 134 controls (110 from NIST 800-171 plus 24 enhanced controls from NIST 800-172).
What Does a C3PAO Assessment Actually Cost?
For small and mid-size defense contractors approaching CMMC Level 2 certification, the total investment is typically higher than anticipated—particularly for organizations that haven't previously implemented a structured cybersecurity program. Based on current market data from C3PAOs and compliance consultants:
- Small contractors (1-50 employees): Total first-year investment of approximately $75,000–$130,000, with C3PAO assessment fees in the $30,000–$50,000 range and preparation and technology costs adding another $35,000–$65,000. Annual ongoing maintenance runs $20,000–$30,000.
- Mid-size contractors (51-200 employees): Total first-year investment of approximately $130,000–$220,000, with assessment fees of $50,000–$80,000 and preparation costs of $65,000–$120,000.
- Large contractors (201-500 employees): Total first-year investment of approximately $220,000–$300,000.
The DoD itself estimates that the 3-year cost for small defense contractors averages $487,970 across the complete compliance lifecycle—a figure that underscores why CMMC preparation should be treated as a long-term operational investment, not a one-time project.
Critically, the assessment fee is only part of the cost. For contractors starting from a low compliance baseline (0-40% of controls implemented), technology and infrastructure remediation can represent 50% or more of total first-year costs. Contractors who begin with a mature security program spend significantly less on remediation.
What Can (and Cannot) Go on a POA&M?
This is one of the most important, and least understood, parts of a CMMC Level 2 assessment. Under 32 CFR 170.21, a plan of action and milestones (POA&M) is not a generic way to extend a failed assessment. Conditional Level 2 status is available only if all of the following are true:
- The assessment score divided by the 110 Level 2 security requirements is at least 0.8, which is a minimum score of 88 under the CMMC scoring methodology in 32 CFR 170.24.
- None of the requirements on the POA&M have a point value greater than 1, except SC.L2-3.13.11 (CUI encryption) may be included if encryption is employed but is not FIPS-validated, which would otherwise be scored as 3 points.
- None of the following requirements are on the POA&M at all: AC.L2-3.1.20 (external connections), AC.L2-3.1.22 (control public information), CA.L2-3.12.4 (system security plan), PE.L2-3.10.3 (escort visitors), PE.L2-3.10.4 (physical access logs), and PE.L2-3.10.5 (manage physical access).
If those conditions are not met, the assessment does not result in conditional status, regardless of how close the overall score is. Remaining POA&M items have to be closed, and confirmed by a closeout assessment, within 180 days of the conditional status date. If they are not closed in time, the conditional status expires. CA.L2-3.12.4, the system security plan, cannot be placed on a POA&M; without an adequate SSP, a Level 2 assessment should not proceed.
Level 3 conditional status has its own, shorter list of requirements that cannot appear on a POA&M, also in 32 CFR 170.21. For how this fits the broader program, see the 2026 CMMC timeline and the C3PAO readiness guide.
What Are the Most Common Risk Assessment Failures for Defense Contractors?
Based on DIBCAC assessment data and C3PAO experience, the most frequent causes of failed or significantly deficient CMMC assessments include:
- Inadequate or missing System Security Plan (SSP): The SSP is the foundational document for CMMC. It must accurately describe your environment, identify all systems in scope, and document how each of the 110 controls is implemented. Many contractors either lack an SSP entirely, have one that doesn't reflect their actual systems, or have a generic template that wasn't tailored to their environment.
- Inflated SPRS self-assessments: Contractors often assess themselves higher than warranted, either from misunderstanding control requirements or from optimism bias. When a C3PAO assessment reveals a large gap between the self-assessment score and the actual implementation state, the contractor faces both a compliance gap and potential legal exposure for submitting inaccurate scores to SPRS.
- Missing MFA: Multi-factor authentication (control 3.5.3) cannot be on a POA&M. It is one of the most commonly cited deficiencies in DIBCAC assessments and one of the easiest to address—yet many small contractors still haven't fully implemented it across all CUI-accessing accounts.
- Inadequate audit logging: Controls 3.3.1 and 3.3.2 (event logging and audit review) are mandatory. Many contractors have logging enabled but insufficient coverage—missing authentication events, privileged access logging, or log retention periods that don't meet the required minimums.
- Scope creep without documentation: Contractors often don't clearly define their CUI boundary, leading to assessment scope that's either too broad (creating unnecessary compliance burden) or too narrow (leaving unprotected systems in CUI data flows). An accurate, documented scope is foundational to a defensible assessment.
- No documented POA&Ms for known gaps: Contractors who know they have gaps but haven't documented formal POA&Ms with target closure dates, responsible parties, and resource allocation are not eligible for conditional CMMC status. The POA&M is not just a list of things to fix—it's a formal management document with specific required elements.
How Should Contractors Structure the Risk Assessment Process?
A structured CMMC risk assessment process follows a logical sequence that aligns with the DoD Assessment Methodology:
- Scoping: Define your CUI boundary by identifying every system, network, and component that processes, stores, or transmits CUI. This defines the scope of your SSP and your CMMC assessment. Keep the scope as narrow as operationally accurate—but don't artificially exclude systems that actually touch CUI.
- Gap assessment: Evaluate your current implementation status against each of the 110 NIST SP 800-171 controls using the DoD Assessment Methodology. For each control, document whether it is fully implemented, partially implemented, or not implemented. Be honest—an inflated gap assessment will produce a false SPRS score.
- SSP development: Create or update your System Security Plan to reflect your actual environment and control implementations. The SSP must include all required sections and accurately describe how each control is implemented—or reference a POA&M for those not yet implemented.
- POA&M creation: For each gap identified, create a formal POA&M entry with: the control ID, description of the deficiency, planned remediation action, responsible party, required resources, and target completion date. POA&Ms must close within 180 days of conditional CMMC status.
- SPRS score calculation and submission: Calculate your score using the DoD Assessment Methodology and submit to SPRS. This score is visible to contracting officers and prime contractors when evaluating your bids.
- C3PAO assessment preparation: If Level 2 certification is required, engage a C3PAO for a pre-assessment gap review before the formal assessment. This gives you an opportunity to identify and remediate issues before the clock starts on your formal assessment.
See also our article on Supply Chain Cybersecurity for DoD Contractors for guidance on how SPRS scores affect subcontractor relationships and prime contractor oversight obligations.
What Should Defense Contractors Do Next?
A CMMC risk assessment is not a box to check. It is the foundation of your program and of an honest SPRS submission. Phase 1 is still active, and contracting officers can still look at SPRS scores before award. Starting that work now is reasonable. Treating 2026 through 2028 as a fixed C3PAO enforcement calendar is not, because Phase 2 is suspended. Watch the official program page for updates.
NorthStar Technology Group conducts CMMC gap assessments and readiness reviews for defense contractors, from initial scoping and system security plan development through preparation for a C3PAO assessment when a contract requires one. A readiness review is not an official assessment. NorthStar does not perform official CMMC assessments. If you want help with that work, see our DoD and CMMC services.
About the author

Ken Satkunam, CISM
President & Founder, NorthStar Technology Group
Ken has spent over 25 years in IT leadership, serving in roles from technical support to CIO for organizations as large as 23,000 employees. He founded NorthStar Technology Group in 2000 to help regulated organizations build secure, compliant, and operationally resilient technology environments. Ken holds the Certified Information Security Manager (CISM) credential from ISACA and is the co-author of the Amazon best-seller "Cyber Attack Prevention." He has been quoted in industry publications including eWeek and DM News, and NorthStar has been recognized on the Inc. 5000 list in both 2024 and 2025.